ORDER-2025-6 : Request to set a public hearing on Classification of Property for December 2, 2024 and Subsequently Determine the Classification of Property.

Transcript (~6 min @ 54:05)

Speakers identified by voice; unnamed voices are numbered within this recording. Auto-caption text — verify against the video.

▶ 53:58 Leila Migliorelli: Seeing no one online, I will motion to, by unanimous consent to close the public hearing and moving on, we will now take up the order, um, the request to, to set the property tax classification. So that's, right now Id, 1 2, 2 14 is before us. Um, and, uh, Councillor ga. Okay.

▶ 54:19 Speaker 2: I apologize.

▶ 54:21 Mark Garipay: It's, it's a different, different way of doing things. I little confused with what we got going on. Yeah, no, not, I would, uh, make a motion for a residential factor of 9.9612

▶ 54:31 Speaker 5: Second. Oh,

▶ 54:33 Leila Migliorelli: Okay. So we have a motion on the table for a residential factor of 0.9612 made by Councilor Repe, seconded by Councillor Stewart on discussion. Councillor Stewart?

▶ 54:43 Robb Stewart: Yes, Madam President. Um, I just wanted to clarify that

▶ 54:49 Speaker 5: this is, uh, 0.9612

▶ 54:52 Robb Stewart: and not 0.9621. Um, because 0.9612 is not on the residential factor. And if you're going off the chart that was given to us, that would be, I think, uh, another calculation that they would need to do. So I just wanted to, I'm looking at this 1.72 is 0.9621, right?

▶ 55:23 Mark Garipay: 1.73 is 0.96. 1 2, 1

▶ 55:27 Robb Stewart: 0.5, 1.76. Just the point of order to make sure we're all on the same page. There's two pages and one, um, We should be looking at number 17, right? Page 17, the

▶ 55:41 Speaker 2: Fourth up from the bottom. Third up from the bottom

▶ 55:46 Robb Stewart: Third up from the bottom is 0.9615

▶ 55:48 Speaker 2: Through the chair. Sorry.

▶ 55:53 Speaker 5: Um, Am I looking at the right one? I mean,

▶ 55:55 Leila Migliorelli: Correct. All right. I, I, yes, I, I am, I am reading Councilor Stewart's. Right? I see 1.73 and I see the factor of 0.9615 on page 17, third up from the bottom. Correct.

▶ 56:07 Speaker 5: Madam chair up. Not page 18.

▶ 56:10 Speaker 9: Councilor Gepe may have in front of him.

▶ 56:12 Speaker 8: Council Romanoff. Oh my,

▶ 56:13 Devin Romanul: My apologies. Just Board, I think. I think, uh, you're referring to page 18. The page bottom

▶ 56:19 Speaker 9: 18 is what? Okay.

▶ 56:28 Robb Stewart: So why are these two different?

▶ 56:32 Robb Stewart: And Madam President, this might be a question for Ms. McClellan.

▶ 56:37 Speaker 9: Yeah, Ms. McClellan, you can come back up to the table.

▶ 56:39 Robb Stewart: Help us. So why is 17 and 18 different?

▶ 56:42 Speaker 10: Okay, 0.9612.

▶ 56:56 Speaker 10: 17. So

▶ 57:00 Speaker 10: 0.962.

▶ 57:08 Speaker 8: Sorry, I'm sorry. I'm actually just,

▶ 57:11 Speaker 9: I can't see on page 18 where, where anyone's looking at.

▶ 57:15 Ryan Williams: Madam Chair, if you look at the second half of the page in the white colored columns, and you count, um, three up from the bottom under residential factor, you'll see 0.9612 for a shift of 1.73 mm-Hmm.

▶ 57:35 Speaker 5: So the, the two charts are, they're just different.

▶ 57:38 Speaker 10: 9, 6, 1 2.

▶ 57:50 Speaker 8: Thank you counselors. Um, Ms. McClellan, can you clarify which chart is the correct one?

▶ 57:57 Speaker 6: Yes. Okay.

▶ 58:11 Speaker 10: It just must have been, uh, incorrect.

▶ 58:33 Speaker 9: Um, I would entertain a motion to recess, if that's okay.

▶ 58:38 Speaker 8: We have the, um, band out there and that might give, uh, Ms.

▶ 58:40 Speaker 9: McClellan a moment to help get things settled. So,

▶ 58:42 Speaker 5: Madam President, I'll make a motion to recess. Second, second,

▶ 58:44 Speaker 9: Second. Motion to

▶ 58:45 Speaker 8: recess made by Councillor Stewart. Second by Councillor Krum. Shady. All in favor? Aye. Aye.

▶ 58:50 Speaker 9: Any opposed? Um, actually, did I say a motion to recess?

▶ 58:55 Speaker 8: We should, you did motion? Um,

▶ 58:59 Speaker 5: Motion To move Now you can figure it

▶ 59:00 Speaker 9: Out. Move. What's the Yeah. Uh, take a motion. Out of order.

▶ 59:04 Speaker 9: Motion Out of order. But we had a motion on the table. We had an, actually we did not have a motion. The table, we moved to open this order.

▶ 59:11 Speaker 5: We do we have a motion in a second for the tax. It was a public Hearing. I'll s my second.

▶ 59:16 Mark Garipay: I'll resend, I'll resend my Motion for the moment.

▶ 59:18 Speaker 9: And so what do we do when we're in the middle

▶ 59:19 Speaker 8: of an order and

▶ 59:22 Speaker 1: He's going to resend the motion of residential factors. 9.9162. You're going to resend You closed public hearing

▶ 59:31 Speaker 9: The Yeah, the public hearing.

▶ 59:32 Speaker 1: And that's basically Where

▶ 59:34 Leila Migliorelli: We were. And we're now in, I had said we did this order in front of us.

▶ 59:40 Speaker 9: This is testing my Robert's Rules of Holding Councilor All.

▶ 59:45 Maya Jamaleddine: So we closed public hearing. We Closed the public hearing. Now He, uh, uh, councilor Garre and his, His motion, his motion. And Councilor Stewart also withdraw his, his second.

▶ 59:59 Speaker 9: But we still have the order before us.

▶ 1:00:02 Speaker 8: But if we wanna continue in the agenda, so if we recessed,

▶ 1:00:04 Speaker 9: but we need to be able to hear that resolution before we go on. Council Stewart.

▶ 1:00:07 Robb Stewart: President, I'll make a motion to, uh, lay the table the motion. Okay, Great. The order. Okay.

▶ 1:00:13 Speaker 9: Motion to lay on the, the order on the table second.

▶ 1:00:15 Speaker 8: And take on the table. Right.

▶ 1:00:18 Speaker 9: Um, motion to lay on the table made by Councillor Stewart.

▶ 1:00:19 Speaker 8: Seconded by Councillor Firo. All in favor? Aye. Aye.